23220 Chagrin Blvd., Suite 476, Beachwood, OH, 44122 chris@emilyjerryfoundation.org 440.289.8662

Pharmacist Sentenced For Toddler’s Death


A former Cleveland area pharmacist got jail time in connection with the death of a toddler.

41-year-old Eric Cropp has been sentenced to six months in jail, six months of house arrest and three years probation in the death of 2-year-old Emily Jerry.

At Friday’s sentencing in Cleveland, Cropp was also ordered to tell professional groups about his case as part of 400 hours of community service when he leaves jail.

Cropp pleaded no contest in May to involuntary manslaughter in the 2006 death.

Prosecutors said Cropp was responsible because he oversaw the mixing of the girl’s chemotherapy at Rainbow Babies and Children’s Hospital in Cleveland.

The toddler received an overdose of a saline solution during chemotherapy and died three days later.

During the sentencing, Emily’s mother spoke to the judge and to Cropp.

“Emily beat her cancer only to suffer a horrific and painful death. Mr. cropp you have no idea how you’ve devastated so many lives. You never will. Even if you were to recieve the maximum of 5 years, it will never compare to the lifetime of pain and suffering I and my family will have to endure,” said Kelly Jerry.

The hospital fired Cropp and his license was revoked.

Article written by ONN news, and can be found on 10tv.com. It was originally posted on 8/14/2009.

19 Comments on “Pharmacist Sentenced For Toddler’s Death

  1. This story brings me to the verge of tears. I’m a nurse, and I have three girls. What a cute kid!

    The pharmacist was working under very adverse circumstances that day, which increased the probability of human error. He is paying with jail time, loss of job, license, money, and freedom. I personally could not live with such a thing on my conscience- I’d likely shoot myself.

    All these other penalties for a huge human screw-up that was unintentional? Well, I can see why you would want strong penalties, but it doesn’t seem right to somebody reading both sides of the story. Why should any of us be in medicine with this sword of Damocles over our heads? If I make a human error I could go to prison and lose everything. Is it worth it? No, it is not! I wish I could bring your little girl back. This hurts, even for somebody that never knew her.

  2. As a hospital pharmacist, Kelly Jerry’s comments to Eric Cropp are deeply troubling to me. I have no doubt that Mr Cropp does have indeed have an idea about the lives that were devastated by this mistake – including his own and his family’s lives. Everyone lost in this scenario. Everyone.

    I agree with the other poster, Tony H – we are all susceptible to human error. It is something I have nightmares about. Unfortunately for those of us in health careers, those errors can result in harm to the patient. We work hard every day to ensure our work is flawless and we continue to make improvements in patient care that make the system better and less prone to errors. It saddens me that a fellow pharmacist has lost his job, his livelihood, and is serving jail time for a mistake.

    Mr and Mrs Jerry, I am deeply sorry for your loss. But I am afraid that such punitive measures will result in attempts to hide errors, shift blame and impede the process of continuous care improvement. No amount of punishment for Mr Cropp will bring back your sweet Emily.

  3. As a pharmacy tech on a naval base, i agree with sarah. I am deeply disturbed by the death and horrified by it. It does sadden me. But we are all human. To avoid errors 100% is impossible. If we was to do that, we techs and pharmacists would all sprout wings and halos. Now i think their definitley should have been a requisite for training and education before this happened. I mean in the navy, pharmacy tech school is 6 months long ususally twice as long as the civilian counterparts. It is said that pharmacists are 99.9% accurate. Sounds nice but when it adds up quickly becomes and ugly picture yes. I think the tech is totally at fault. If something in your mind raises a red flag but yet you ignore it knowing gosh darn (using censorship here) well that what you are filling/mixing could be harmful or fatal, that is just so stupid, ignorant, dumb and so forth. And plus it is said she was busy planning her wedding. Yeah planning her wedding while the Jerry’s were planning a funeral. I dont know how that ex-tech lives with herself. I think however that yes the pharmacist should have caught the error, criminal charges? Is joking ya are? Come on now America

  4. “Mr. cropp you have no idea how you’ve devastated so many lives. You never will. Even if you were to recieve the maximum of 5 years, it will never compare to the lifetime of pain and suffering I and my family will have to endure,” said Kelly Jerry.”

    Are you sure Mr. Cropp isn’t aware he allowed an incompetent employee, keep her job? Awareness is justice, to target one person for a trail of mistakes isn’t . Human error is sometimes deadly which is very unfortunate. Unless someone has malicous intent, can they be held totally responsible? Lesson…get rid of incompetent slackers in the job field quickly. Justice is blind in this country…..I have no doubt that if Little Emily was poor and from the inner city, there would have been a whole different outcome. It’s good that the techs are required to get training for compitence, but can anyone seriously say justice was served here?

  5. I don’t care if it was an unintentional mistake. “I didn’t mean to” is a lame excuse. If you make a mistake, and that mistake results in someone’s death, you step up and take responsibility for it. You willingly pay the consequences. That’s what decent, mature people do.

    Careless actions have consequences, regardless of what the intentions or motives were.

    • Josh, I have been a pharmacist for 25 years and an oncology pharmacist for 17 years and everyday when I go to work, I know that one mistake could cost someone their life. I would be devastated to know that I cost someone their life, but I do consider it “murder” or I ” killed someone”. Those are two situations when criminal charges are appropriate, but this case fits neither of those scenarios. I do think the family should be awarded a monetary settlement and the pharmacist should be reprimanded and possibly lose his job, but not his license and livelihood. Jail time, really. We, as pharmacist, are not gods and we make mistakes, as I have. I am just fortunate enough, not have made a deadly mistake in my career, which is not over and I pray that mistake never happens, but I do carry malpractice insurance, because I know I am not perfect and that mistake could happen and you need to think about what you say before you say it because you just sound like an angry little man who doesn’t know the first thing about the responsibility of the medical professionals who work so hard on a daily basis to keep you healthy.

  6. Not just careless actions have consequences all actions have consequnces as this pharmacist has known for his entire career. That doesn’t change the fact that humans make mistakes and mistakes can lead to terrible consequences. For every 1000 medications a pharmacist will make one error. That is just a statistic. This was one of his mistakes and now his entire life if ruined.

    I totally agree that Mr./Mrs. Jerry should be monetarily compensated (and I’m sure they were), but what does ending this mans career and ruining his life do to make this mistake be reversed? Nothing whatsoever. This punishment is purely for reasons of revenge on the part of the plaintiff (I have had a sibling and other close friends/ family members die so don’t say anything about how I can’t relate). I cannot believe this woman called him a muderer. He didn’t have any intent to cause harm to anyone. This was an accident just like a driver may have an “accident” and kill someone while following all laws and being cautions and they would never go to jail for six months and have six months of house arrest. This case set a precedence for health care providers and it wasn’t a good one.

    The notion that a pharmacists duty is to be 100% accurate is ludacris. For example physicians aren’t expected to diagnose correctly 100% of the time why is there this double standard with pharmacy and with the health care field in general.

    • You can’t compare the loss of a child to your other “close friends/family’. Don’t even go there. Child loss is the worst out there. I had so many losses in life, so many, but losing 2 kids was by far the worst ones of all. There was someone who contributed to one of my daughter’s death and I think she should suffer the consequences for doing so Everyone makes “mistakes”, but we all don’t kill people

  7. The Jerry’s say MURDER … be careful what you wish for .. punish yes .. a fine license suspension .. community service lectures … JAIL ? OHIO JUSTICE IS NUTS !! Who trained the Technician? … The Hospital mush carry some blame .. all too often I see Hospitals CUT COSTS … DANCE AROUND POLICIES POORLY WRITTEN … only to blame the Nurse, Pharmacist, Physician Interns/residents, etc.
    Not to sound TOO cold but were there any other comorbities attendant here given the delay to death of 3 days ? Was the Tech fired also?
    It is indeed very sad for a 2yr old baby to die, but an injustice to the Pharmacist here is NOT any way to handle this!!

    • This is my daughter Emily Jerry’s story, in detail that is very difficult to set down. But it’s a story that needs to be shared, both due to the medical tragedy that occurred and so we all can learn from this heartbreaking story. It is through this process we can ultimately improve America’s healthcare system by making it safer for everyone receiving medical care. Additionally, I want to come forward as Emily’s father and publicly forgive Eric Cropp, as well as, the pharmacy technician involved. I do believe, in my heart, they are part of this tragedy. Eric and the pharmacy technician are also victims of an ineffective patient safety system. Along those lines, I want everyone to know that I also feel very strongly that Eric should have never been charged criminally with what happened to my beautiful daughter Emily. The criminal charges that Eric faced, were pursued by the prosecutor’s office, as well as, my former wife, Kelly Jerry and her father Lloyd Buck. Due to the fact that there was absolutely no criminal intent on the part of Eric Cropp or the pharmacy technician, I chose to bow out of media spotlight during these legal proceedings. There was absolutely no malice shown by anyone involved the day Emily was accidently overdosed on sodium chloride. Subsequently, through my actions and how I now lead my life, I also wish to set an example of forgiveness and show how a terrible blow can induce a person to turn it to good works. I devote my time, fully, now to the work of The Emily Jerry Foundation (emilyjerryfoundation.org) and to my various public service activities. I am determined to get this story told and elevate the issues involved for the good of all.

      The Emily Jerry Foundation has been established on the premise that each and every child born into this world is truly a miracle. With that thought in mind, we believe that every child on this planet should be treated and cared for as such. Every baby that is born is truly a gift from God! The core of the Emily Jerry Foundation focuses on protecting our nation’s babies and children from the all too redundant medical errors that keep occurring over and over again in hospitals across the nation. These countless mistakes are killing our children and are most often avoidable. We are increasing public awareness of these issues and striving to get better legislation in place across the United States. The Emily Jerry Foundation is helping to save countless lives, as well as, make our world-renowned medical facilities much safer.

      Again, as Emily’s father, I would like one day be in a position to be able to publicly forgive Eric Cropp and the pharmacy technician on national television.

      • I saw you on Dr Oz today and wanted to express my deepest sympathy for the loss of your precious child Emily. You’re incredibly gracious and I was deeply moved as you absolutely didn’t blame Mr Eric Cropp. I can see how devastated he was and that man will have to live with that guilt for the rest of his w. I truly do admire that you are both working together to prevent this from ever happening to another person. Emily is an Angel and God bless you and Emily 🙏🏻❤️

    • Dear Francis,

      I just wanted to correct you on something that’s very important. I have never said that the pharmacist or pharmacy technician murdered my daughter Emily. My former wife Kelly Jerry, her father Lloyd Buck, and the prosecutor, Bill Mason, are the ones who actually pursued criminal charges against them. In a majority of these tragic cases, there is absolutely no malicious intent by the individual who actually makes the mistake. In my limited opinion, most people are really not cognisant of the fact that, in medicine, there will always be the “human error” component. With this thought in mind, I believe it’s wrong for our nation’s judicial system to charge these people who make these errors criminally. Subsequently, I truly believe that these individuals that have actually made these mistakes are part of the over all tragedy. In my opinion, these people are also victims of an ineffective patient safety system. In most cases, their lives are completely ruined as a result of what transpires after an accident occurs. Please get your facts straight next time Francis!

      Very best regards,


  8. This brings me to tears because I am in school for Pharmacy Tech and the main thing we learn is that MISTAKES=DEATH and I would not be able to live with myself is someone died due to my own mishap…..

  9. Chris,….it’s Trish, we just met the other day in regards to your car.

    I finally got a chance to sit down and check out the site.
    I had no idea you lost your beautiful little girl, I am deeply sorry for this tragedy.

    I have to admire your strength in the face of something so devastating. Of course I’d heard the news stories, but I would never imagine a person like yourself having suffered such a blow….. and how admirable of you to focus your energies towards making something good/productive out of it.

    After I’d spoken with you and your lady the other day, I left thinking “Such nice people, what a refreshing ‘change of pace’ to the ‘folks’ I typically interact with during my work day! “. Now reading your story, I feel privileged to have met you.



    • Hi Trish,

      Thank you, so much, for your kind words and for taking the time to visit The Emily Jerry Foundation’s website. It’s this kind of support, from people like yourself, that really helps keep me going on daily basis!

      Best regards,


  10. I turned on my TV and caught the tail end of you forgiving the pharmacist on the Oz show. I immediately looked up the Emily Jerry foundation and read the story. I’m in tears and completely choked up! My heart goes out to everyone. I never realize that pharmacy techs can work without ample training. Is 6 months really enough for a pharmacy tech?. It seems to me that someone working with something that could be so dangerous would have to have a lot more than 6 months for training.
    I haven’t looked up the standard time of training throughout the country but that is my next step. My heart goes out to all of you especially Little Emily and all the other children that have been harmed.

  11. Just saw the episode of Dr. Oz.
    My heart reaches out to both men, the father, and the pharmacist. I’ve read lots and lots of comments. I must say that I agree that the hospital should’ve been accountable. A tech with zero experience? In a hospital? Ludicrous!! And what I’m surprised about that I haven’t seen mentioned: why is there also no accountability on the part of the hospital regarding the amount of overtime (a THIRD double shift in a row) of Mr. Cropp? That’s a job dealing with life and death! Seems wrong to me that he was so overworked. I’m so encouraged by Mr. Jerry’s forgiveness and ongoing foundation work. My best to Mr. Cropp. You’re both in the hands of the ultimate in forgiving others.

  12. Chris, I am terribly sorry for you losing your precious Emily! I had a full-term stillbirth, so I can only partially know your pain. I hope all the good memories of her will bring you comfort.

    I saw you on Dr. Oz; I’m so happy that you were given the national platform that you wanted to show your forgiveness for Eric Cropp. The fact that you can be so gracious & forgiving after also losing your family, is amazing, & very inspiring!

    I am a Registered Nurse, & see both sides of this tragedy. You are such a phenomenal role model on how to turn tragedy into something that makes the world a better place! Thank-you from the bottom of my heart for your INCREDIBLE mission, & being a tremendous role model for our society!

    My heart hurts for Eric Clopp, the pharmacist; he was definitely thrown under the bus. It’s obvious that he is a caring individual, & didn’t want patients to get poor care, because he went in when the hospital was short-staffed, after working doubles the two days before! The hospital was negligent for putting him in that situation! They were also at fault for having an untrained tech in such an important role; no doubt a “cost-saving” measure!! It blows my mind that the hospital & tech were not held responsible, & that he got jail time!! MAJOR MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE!!

    Praying that Eric Cropp is able to find peace, & release his guilt so he can have some joy in life again. Also praying that your ex-wife and children can work through their grief & let go of their anger & hatred to allow them to experience happiness. Hopefully after this healing, your family can be reunited.

  13. Mr. Jerry,

    As a registered nurse at the bedside for 10 years, an administrator of quality for 5 years and now a nursing educator, I teach your daughter’s story to highlight how precious life is and how we, as clinicians, cannot afford to become numb to the work that we do on a day to day basis. It is easy to fall into the trap of thinking I’ve done this task a million times. The reality is the one time you take your eye off the ball could be the one time that a tragedy such as the one that has affected your family occurs.

    I feel such deep sorrow for the loss of your precious Emily. I also feel sorrow for the way the system handled this pharmacist. No one that I have come across in my entire career is unfeeling or uncaring about patients or families but the fact remains that we are human and errors do occur.

    There is so much that can be done to help prevent harm in this industry and I am very impressed with the way that you have taken your family’s pain and honored the memory of your Emily. May God bless you and yours.

    Sincerely, Suzette Davidson BSN RN

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *